Strength Evaluation
Which of the following two counters is stronger?

nlite relies on user feedback to rank submitted counters. Please compare the strength of the two counters below, ignoring all others.

The platform identifies the top counters to each argument independently of other arguments. This implies that the competition occurs among counters challenging the same argument.

Counter A

Acting morally due to fear of divine punishment may reflect obedience, not ethical virtue. True morality requires internal motivation, such as empathy or rational reflection—not just fear-based compliance.

Counter B

Studies show that atheists and agnostics often score high on measures of charity, honesty, and prosocial behavior. See here.

Overview